What To Do When Founders Want To Sell Shares

Jun 2 2014, 5:00pm CDT | by

From time to time founders approach the board and investors of a private company and ask to sell stock*. Often this happens when the company is raising money, and the founders want to “sell into the financing”. Sometimes it takes the form of an isolated, direct deal between a founder and an investor.

I appreciate that founders have personal lives, wives, and families, and they need to pay for houses, cars, vacations, and college educations. They’ve often been at it for years before investors come on the scene, and they see the enormous progress that has been made from day one, even if there is also a long way to go.

Still, the founders and key executives play a special role in a small company: they embody the promise of the company and the drive to make it succeed. When I am an investor, I like it when a founder works to preserve every tenth of a percentage point of equity ownership: it reassures me that our stock is valuable, and that s/he is fighting every day to make it more valuable. By the same token, it’s a bit unsettling when a founder wants to sell.

In its early stages, a company often has limited access to capital. Operating cash flow is usually deeply negative. The investors at the table can put in only a certain amount of money, and a new investor may not step up on reasonable terms until the company achieves key milestones. At this stage, founders taking money out put the company at added risk of running out of money prematurely and needing to raise capital with its back against the wall. In the worst case this can lead to a distress sale or shut down.

Then there is the question of pricing the shares. Early-stage companies mostly sell preferred shares to investors, and founders mostly hold common shares that they acquired at a very low price when the company was formed. Usually there have been no transactions in these common shares, so there is no market pricing information. Companies often hire valuation consultants to do a “409a” valuation of common shares**. 409a valuations are done to facilitate the award of incentive stock options (ISOs) to employees: the lower the price can be, the better. Valuation is always subjective, and 409a valuation consultants know that they are hired to provide the lowest valuation of common shares that can be justified.

So, the 409a valuation price is probably less than an investor would be willing to pay. Trading common shares at the preferred share price, as founders sometimes suggest, is not good either: preferred shares have superior economic and governance rights to common shares; for that reason they are worth more. The right answer is in between, and where it lies between the preferred share price and the 409a valuation of common shares, which is often 20% of the preferred price, is not obvious.

Also, sale of common shares at a price above the 409a valuation undermines the credibility of the 409a valuation. So the next 409a valuation will take this new price into account, and future incentive options issued to employees will need to have higher striking prices, which reduces their value as a performance incentive.

Founders sometimes ask that the company buy back their shares. When a financing is about to occur and money is coming in, “selling into the financing” (selling shares to the company which are paid for with money raised in the financing) is quick and easy way for founders to achieve liquidity. It takes cash off of the company’s balance sheet, however. And a purchase of stock by the company from a key employee makes the Board of Directors responsible for determining valuation, however. Typically the Board consists of one or two founders, a few outside investors, and one or two others. Usually, the founders selected several of the other directors. Asking the board to set the price can create a difficult conflict of interest.

Here’s where we as a partnership have come to on this issue:

• We’re not excited about founders selling shares. We’d prefer that everyone keep his or her money in the pot and share together in the liquidity event towards which we are all working. And, we’ve found that when founders cash out a large percentage of their equity, they often check out, too. So the request to sell can be a sign that new management will soon be needed.

• However, if the company has reached the point at which its future access to financing has only moderate risk, and if the founders feel strongly they need some liquidity, we can support sale of a small fraction of founder shares. Moderate risk means that the company is able to fund its essential ongoing needs with internally generated cash flow (or close to that point), and it is doing well against its plans and goals, and hence likely to be able to raise outside capital if needed.

• We push hard for the common shares to be sold directly to an investor at a negotiated price. This provides a “skin-in-the-game” valuation. And it makes it more likely that the money paid for the common shares is incremental money, rather than a diversion of funds that would otherwise be available to the company.

============

*Many small companies with outside investors have agreements that prohibit one shareholder from selling stock without the agreement of the board and a super-majority of the other shareholders.

**The name refers to Section 409(a) of the Internal Revenue Code, which establishes the need for these valuations.

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

China Auto Update: 2014 First Half
China Auto Update: 2014 First Half
Despite a slowing economy, China’s auto industry sales were strong during the first six months of the year. Passenger car sales registered a double-digit increase of 11 percent to 9.6 million units during the period as...
 
 
Earnings Preview: China Growth to Drive GM's Earnings
General Motors is scheduled to announce its Q2 FY14 earnings on July 24. In the first quarter, GM’s earnings were down on account of high expenses related to car recalls and unfavorable currency translations. However, a...
 
 
India Is High On Japan's Investment Radar
Japanese institutional investors have ranked India number one with regard to investment potential in comparison to key emerging markets, according to a recent report by Nomura, the Tokyo-based lender. Nomura’s...
 
 
2015 Dodge Challenger SRT Hellcat: Top 10 Amazing Facts about America's Most Powerful Car
2015 Dodge Challenger SRT Hellcat: Top 10 Amazing Facts about America's Most Powerful Car
No matter how you slice the data, Chrysler is enjoying great success in the automotive world. At Kelley Blue Book we’ve watched shopper traffic across every Chrysler division (Chrysler, Dodge, Fiat, Jeep, and Ram)...
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

UN agencies call for actions against polio in Syria
Geneva, July 23 (IANS) The World Health Organisation and the United Nations International Children's Emergency Fund Tuesday said in a report that actions are needed to protect children against polio in Syria as polio...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Kevin Spacey offered donation to turn vegetarian
Los Angeles, July 23 (IANS) Actor Kevin Spacey has been offered a donation of $6,000 to his theatre company by animal rights campaigners if he switches meat for vegetarian food at an upcoming fundraising barbecue. The...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
22 killed in Baghdad bomb attack
Baghdad, July 23 (IANS) At least 22 people were killed and 45 were wounded in a car bomb explosion in the capital Baghdad Tuesday, a source from the interior ministry said. A suicide bomber blew up himself at a...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Apple TV Is A Huge Cash Cow, Which Is Why Apple Is In No Rush To Make It Better
There is one thing standing between Apple TV and being the number one media player, and that’s the enormous pile of money it’s making. According to the firm, Apple TV has now made $1 billion in media sales. These are...
Read more on Apple Balla
 
Every iPhone Has A Security Backdoor. Apple Denies It Is A Threat
iPhone and iPad users have long been able to laud the superior security of their devices over rivals. But it seems one crucial aspect has been forgotten: what if the hacker is Apple? Responding to an eye opening talk...
Read more on Apple Balla
 
Katie Price still loves cheating husband
London, July 23 (IANS) Former model Katie Price wanted to "throttle" her cheating husband Kieran Hayler, but that doesn't stop her from loving him. She was left broken hearted when she discovered her husband had...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Lana Del Rey: I've 'slept with a lot of famous guys'
Lana Del Rey claims she's ''slept with a lot of guys in the industry''. The 27-year-old singer admits she's been romantically involved with a number of famous people in the past but none of them helped kick-start her...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Shia LaBeouf wants to stay sober for Brad Pitt
Shia LaBeouf is determined to stay sober for Brad Pitt. The troubled star - who is currently on an outpatient program for alcohol abuse - is trying hard to kick his addiction to booze as he's afraid of embarrassing his...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Kate Hudson has 'unconventional' life
Kate Hudson thinks she has an ''unconventional'' life. The actress insists her life is far from normal but she tries to make sure her children, Ryder, 10, whom she has with ex-husband Chris Robinson, and Bingham, three...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Snoop Dogg smoked cannabis at White House
Snoop Dogg smoked cannabis at the White House. The 42-year-old rapper - whose real name is Calvin Cordozar Broadus Jr. - admits he once puffed on marijuana in the bathroom at the official residence of president Barack...
Read more on Celebrity Balla