Why Corporate Mergers of Equals Almost Never Work

Jun 5 2014, 11:42am CDT | by

Paris. Champagne. The Arc de Triomphe in the background. It was the perfect setting to announce an engagement. The $35-billion “merger of equals” between advertising giants Omnicom Group and French rival Publicis Groupe seemed richly blessed last July when chief  executives John Wren and Maurice Levy posed for photographs and spoke of creating “a new company for a new world.”

Then this May 9 came the terse announcement that the marriage was off. Omnicom blamed cultural differences; Publicis complained about “inequality.” Whatever the reason, given the history of mergers of equals these companies and their stakeholders should be relieved this deal didn’t go through.

Like the story of Romeo and Juliet, many a corporate marriage begins as a romance filled with promise only to end in disaster. Corporate marriages often go wrong, but mergers of equals—in which two firms of roughly similar size combine, with neither a buyer nor a target and typically no cash changing hands—account for a disproportionate share of disastrous failures.

Take, for example, the union of Daimler and Chrysler. That 1998 merger of equals created the giant German-American carmaker DaimlerChrysler. Just two years later Jürgen Schrempp, by now in sole command, having seen off Robert Eaton, the former head of Chrysler, claimed that the term “merger of equals” had been used only for “psychological reasons,” thereby effectively acknowledging that equality was just a word used to sell the deal to Chrysler folk. It was a Daimler takeover. The marriage struggled on until May 2007, when a divorce was announced.

Which raises a question: Is there really such thing as a merger of equals? Some people don’t think so. George Sard, chief executive of the strategic communications firm Sard Verbinnen, says, “Mergers of equals have long been among the most challenging deals from a communications perspective, because of the internal politics involved and because nobody believes there really is such a thing.”

There is, in fact, a financial and legal framework that enables companies to combine with no designated acquirer. Both companies are made equal as far as the technicalities of the deal are concerned. To give form to this equality, the board of directors of the combined company is split equally between directors from each company. There is also typically a brokered power-sharing arrangement among the chief executives, both wanting to be perceived as winners. The shareholders from each company retain ownership in the combined entity, since the deal is structured as a stock-for-stock tax-free exchange.

From this point on the question becomes, where does equality end? Very few CEOs have found an answer. But human nature and corporate ego being what they are, the next time is always going to be different. So, in spite of the cautionary tale of DaimlerChrysler, toxic marriages have continued.

There was Pharmacia and Upjohn, for example. Here was a transnational merger of equals between two pharmaceutical giants, Pharmacia of Sweden and Upjohn of the U.S., in which equality became a euphemism for stalemate and deadlock between two rival cultures.

After years of declining profits, the departure of many senior people, and plummeting morale, a new CEO stepped in. One of Fred Hassan’s first acts as CEO was symbolic: He renamed the company Pharmacia, to clearly signal a new one-company direction.

Most notorious of all was the stunning $350-billion merger of equals between Time Warner and AOL. Not on any basis were they equal. Time Warner, the media giant, had 70,000 employees and revenues of $27 billion; AOL’s 12,000 employees generated less than $5 billion. And they were culturally on different planets. The Internet bubble stock valuation of AOL was propping up the financial logic of the deal, and the world’s biggest online service was expected to inject its “Internet DNA” into the stodgy media giant Time Warner.

So on that heady day in January 2001 when CEOs Steve Case and Jerry Levin literally embraced and announced the creation of their star-crossed merger of equals, the largest in U.S. history, the stage was set once again for a corporate drama in which rivalries, feuds, and names were central to the plot. The ensuing turf wars at AOL Time Warner, as it became, and the struggle to merge two distinctly unequal and disparate cultures, soon overwhelmed the media giant.

Months later the dotcom bubble burst, and the stock collapsed. Jerry Levin announced his retirement in December 2001. In 2009 AOL was spun off. Jeff Bewkes, Time Warner’s current chairman, calls the merger the “biggest mistake in corporate history.”

If Messrs. Wren and Levy needed an example of a French-U.S. merger gone wrong, they would have done well to study the merger of equals between Alcatel and Lucent.

After failing in 2001 to complete a merger because they couldn’t agree on how to share power, Alcatel, a French telecoms-equipment firm, and Lucent, an American rival, eventually tied the knot in 2006, creating Alcatel-Lucent. Relations between CEO Patricia Russo, the former chief of Lucent, and Chairman Serge Tchuruk, Alcatel’s CEO, had already been problematic, according to observers.

The company struggled with integration issues, as cultural differences sparked intense rivalry between the North American entity and the European organization. After six successive quarters of losses, the Paris-based company chose a Dutchman, Ben Verwaayen, to replace Russo as CEO. Tchuruk stepped down as chairman.

Both Tchuruk and Russo pinpointed the heart of the problem with all such mergers when they announced their resignations: “It is now time that the company acquires a personality of its own, independent from its two predecessors,” they said in a joint statement.

There it is: A sense of equality does not build a unifying culture. It  is rather a principle on which separation is guaranteed and perpetuated to the detriment of all concerned, except, perhaps, the lawyers. Collaboration becomes nothing more than a series of trades in an environment where one plus one merely equals one plus one. Far from being merged, the two organizations are simply conjoined, as all their names have proclaimed—AOL-Time Warner, Pharmacia & Upjohn, Alcatel-Lucent, DaimlerChrysler. Eventually, the rudderless behemoth spins out of control until the whole thing falls apart or someone takes control./>/>

George Sard believes that in the future investors will likely demand more clarity up front on such key matters as leadership, board structure, governance, headquarters location, and name. He should have added brand, as the whole process of building a brand is the crucible in which a transformational culture is forged around a defining purpose.

In the meantime, companies that are merging should drop the use of the word “equals.” They should abandon the phrase “a merger of equals” altogether. Call it a “strategic combination,” or a “new corporate entity creation.” A least investors, customers, and employees will know what they’re in for.

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

HSBCVoice: What's Driving Mexico's Growth?
HSBCVoice: What's Driving Mexico's Growth?
By Daniel Broderick Mexico’s increasing purchasing power, as well as key reforms passed by recently elected President Enrique Peña Nieto, have contributed to what economic experts at HSBC say may become the world’s...
 
 
Google Dominates Autonomous Cars Influence as Auto Makers Lag Behind
Google Dominates Autonomous Cars Influence as Auto Makers Lag Behind
Self-driving cars are not yet on dealer lots, but the space is heating up and it’s being led by tech companies while traditional automakers make efforts to catch-up. A new Appinions’ Influence study released today,...
 
 
Vision Without Execution Is Just Hallucination
Vision Without Execution Is Just Hallucination
The title of this blog post is actually the favorite saying of serial entrepreneur, Steve Adams (thanks, Steve), and one of his heroes, Thomas Edison. A great vision is the table stakes for building a valuable business...
 
 
Interesting GM Put And Call Options For March 2015
Interesting GM Put And Call Options For March 2015
Investors in General Motors Co. (NYSE: GM) saw new options begin trading this week, for the March 2015 expiration. One of the key data points that goes into the price an option buyer is willing to pay, is the time value...
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Somali lawmaker, driver gunned down
Mogadishu, July 23 (IANS) Somali lawmaker Saado Ali Warsame and her driver were killed by suspected Islamist gunmen Wednesday in a drive-by shooting in the capital Mogadishu, police and witnesses said. The lawmaker,...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Two Ukrainian military jets shot down in restive east
Kiev, July 23 (IANS) Two Ukrainian fighter jets were shot down in rebel-held eastern regions, the country's defence ministry said Wednesday. "We have information about the downed fighter jets; now we are investigating...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Why it makes sense for iOS 8 and Yosemite to launch separately
Apple’s new operating systems for mobile devices and computers will not launch simultaneously, 9to5Mac has learned from sources familiar with the matter, but that’s not necessarily surprising, even though iOS and OS X...
Read more on Apple Balla
 
HSBCVoice: What's Driving Mexico's Growth?
By Daniel Broderick Mexico’s increasing purchasing power, as well as key reforms passed by recently elected President Enrique Peña Nieto, have contributed to what economic experts at HSBC say may become the world’s...
Read more on Auto Balla
 
Apple denies intentionally compromising iOS security, explains ‘backdoor’ features
Following an extensive security report from an iOS forensic and security expert that questioned some of Apple’s iOS tools when it comes to the user’s security and privacy (see his questions in the image above), Apple...
Read more on Apple Balla
 
Google Dominates Autonomous Cars Influence as Auto Makers Lag Behind
Self-driving cars are not yet on dealer lots, but the space is heating up and it’s being led by tech companies while traditional automakers make efforts to catch-up. A new Appinions’ Influence study released today,...
Read more on Auto Balla
 
UN warns of possible Israeli war crimes in Gaza
Geneva/Jerusalem, July 23 (IANS/EFE) UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay Wednesday warned that Israeli military attacks on Gaza could constitute a war crime, as the death toll in Israel's two-week...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Online visa for Indians travelling to Bahrain
New Delhi, July 23 (IANS) Indians travelling to Bahrain will be able to apply for electronic visas from October this year under new visa rules announced in the Gulf country. Such e-visas can be obtained ahead of...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Indian girls eyeing a winning start against Canada
Glasgow, July 23 (IANS) The mix of youth and experience will be the key for India when the women's hockey team starts its campaign against Canada in the 2014 Commonwealth Games here Thursday. Both the teams have faced...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
23 more killed in Israeli offensive, Gaza toll 650
Gaza, July 23 (IANS) Israel's large-scale offensive continues to wreak havoc on the Gaza Strip, killing 23 Palestinians and wounding around 230 others Wednesday and pushing the toll in the coastal enclave to over 650...
Read more on Politics Balla